Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Watertown Menus

a plate of food on a table

Main Menu

  • Slow Roasted Baby Back Ribs

    Carolina gold BBQ, red potato salad, cherry peppers

    $15

  • New Orleans Style Street Corn

    chili-cheese crumbs, Creole mayo, jalapeno cheese, hot pepper jelly

    $9

  • Spicy Fried Cauliflower

    goat's milk feta, everything spice, pickled onion, red jalapeno vinaigrette

    $12

  • Pork Belly Cracklings

    cheddar salt, honey-mustard

    $11

  • Crawfish & Dumplings

    celery root, sassafras, black pepper, white wine

    $15

  • 2 Prime Burger Sliders*

    andouille spice, muffuletta relish, crunchy garlic cream

    $12

  • Nashville Alligator Fries

    crinkle cut pickles, pimento queso, comeback sauce

    $15

  • Cajun Grilled Swordfish*

    warm crab salad, asparagus, lemon mayo, chile oil

    $16

  • Signature Warm Honey Glazed Biscuits

    smoked cinnamon butter & pimento cheese spread

    $14

  • Cast Iron Baked Brie**

    spiced pecans, Steen's syrup, gooseberries, onion toast

    $18

  • Ham & Potato Croquettes

    grafton cheddar, tomato aioli, shaved mushroom salad

    $10

  • New Orleans BBQ Shrimp

    creamy jalapeno grits, holy trinity, Tasso Ham

    $15

  • Creamy Vidalia Onion Dip

    horseradish-cheddar kettle chips, crispy leeks

    $8

  • Blackened Octopus

    fingerling yams, spicy citrus relish, lemon-honey

    $17

  • 2 Fried Chicken Sliders

    smoked Nashville mayo, pickled green tomato, shredded lettuce

    $14

  • Aged Gouda Mac N' Cheese

    pork scraps, red hot Cheeto crust, fresh chives

    $15

  • Red Apple Wedge**

    Clemson blue cheese dressing, thick cut bacon, candied walnuts

    $10

  • House Special Buttermilk Fried Chicken

    Chicken Wings $13

    Boneless Fried Thighs $15

    Bone-In ½ Chicken $21

    Nashville Hot, Sweet & Spicy, BBQ Syrup or White BBQ Sauce

  • Golden Beet Salad**

    preserved kumquats, smoked yogurt, pistachio & pumpkin seed granola, Banyuls vinaigrette

    $12

  • Steamed Maine Mussels

    tarragon chowder, black pepper bacon bits, applewood smoked oyster crackers

    $15

Below Sea Level

  • Oysters on The ½ Shell*

    malt vinegar mignonette, Crystal cocktail sauce, Atomic horseradish cream

    1/2 Dozen $18

    Dozen $34

  • Jumbo Peel & Eat Shrimp Cocktail

    Crystal cocktail sauce, Atomic horseradish cream, white BBQ sauce

    1/2 Dozen $24

    Dozen $46

Dessert

  • Fresh Fried Beignets

    powdered sugar

    $10

    Make it chocolate $1

    Make it à la mode $2

  • Soft Serve of The Day

    $5

    Add artisan cone $1

  • Sticky Toffee Bread Pudding

    bourbon sauce, brown butter pastry cream

    $12

Buttermilk Merch

  • Jason’s Cookbook

    Buttermilk & Bourbon: New Orleans Recipes with a Modern Flair

    $21.99

  • Buttermilk Hats & T-Shirts

    $20

  • Buttermilk Hoodies

    $45

Bourbon

  • 1792 Small Batch

    $12

  • 4 Roses Small Batch

    $11

  • Angel’s Envy

    $16

  • Angel’s Envy Cask Strength

    $45

  • Basil Hayden’s

    $14

  • Baker’s

    $16

  • Blanton’s Single Barrel

    $17

  • Booker’s

    $23

  • Buffalo Trace

    $10

  • Bulleit

    $13

  • Eagle Rare 10 yr

    $12

  • Jim Beam

    $9

  • Knob Creek Small Batch

    $13

  • Maker’s Mark

    $12

  • Old Forester Rye

    $13

  • Woodford Reserve B&B’s Personal Select

    $15

  • Hudson Baby Bourbon

    $15

1792 Flight Board

  • Ask your server about today’s pours!

    $16

Rye

  • Bulleit Rye

    $13

  • Knob Creek Small Batch Rye

    $13

  • Old Overholt Rye

    $9

  • Sazerac Rye

    $10

  • Whistle Pig 10 Year Rye

    $20

  • Woodford Reserve Rye

    $17

Scotch & Whiskey

  • Crown Royal

    $12

  • Glenlivet 12 Year

    $15

  • Jack Daniel’s

    $10

  • Jameson

    $10

  • Toki

    $14

  • Johnnie Walker Black

    $14

  • Lagavulin 16 Year

    $27

  • Macallan 12 Year

    $20

  • Oban 14 Year

    $25

Cocktails

  • Cafe Du Monde

    Grey Goose vodka, St. George New Orleans coffee liqueur, Irish cream, white creme de cocoa, brulee top, cold brew

    $14

  • Buttermilk's Own Sazerac

    Old Forester Rye, absinthe, chicory pecan bitters, Peychaud's bitters

    $13

  • B & B Hurricane

    Bacardi Rum, passion fruit, pineapple, lime, orange, grenadine

    $14

  • Sangria by Thuy

    Bacardi rums, peach, red wine, citrus

    $12

  • Voodoo Priestess

    Grey Goose vodka, Jenwey special tea blend, lemon, honey

    $13

  • Papillon Gin Fizz

    Oxley gin, butterfly pea tea, lemon, egg white, vanilla cream

    $14

  • The Carousel

    Corazon reposado, Ancho Reyes, Banane Du Bresil, lime, chili oil

    $14

  • Chocolate Praline Old Fashioned**

    Makers Mark, chocolate bitters, candied pecan

    $13

  • Crime of Passion

    1792 bourbon, Chinola passion fruit liqueur, Guapo's love potion #9, Luxardo cherry, orange

    $13

Email Signup

Please check errors in the form above
Thank you for signing up for email updates!

Reservations

Please check errors in the form above
Thanks!